Controversial No-Call on Targeting highlights Texas’ Double OT Win over Arizona State in Peach Bowl

The Peach Bowl ended in controversy on Wednesday as Texas defeated Arizona State 39-31 in double overtime, following a contentious no-call on a helmet-to-helmet hit late in regulation.

With just over a minute left and the game tied at 24-24, Arizona State faced a pivotal third-and-15 at their own 38-yard line. Sun Devils quarterback Sam Leavitt completed a short pass to Melquan Stovall, who was hit hard by Texas safety Michael Taaffe. The collision left Stovall sprawled on the turf, and replays clearly showed helmet-to-helmet contact.

Despite reviewing the play for potential targeting, referee Larry Smith ruled no penalty, leaving Arizona State with a fourth-and-5. A targeting call would have granted the Sun Devils a 15-yard penalty and a first down at the Texas 37, possibly setting up a game-winning field goal attempt.

Instead, Arizona State punted, sending the game into overtime.

Arizona State head coach Kenny Dillingham voiced his frustration over the decision. “I’m going to be honest, I don’t know what targeting is,” he said, referencing a prior targeting penalty that sidelined star defensive back Shamari Simmons for the first half of the game.

Targeting, which involves leading with the crown of the helmet during a hit, has been a point of contention in college football. While Taaffe’s helmet made clear contact with Stovall, it appeared he did not lower his head, a key criterion for the call.

“I just don’t quite understand it,” Dillingham added. “I want to protect the players, and I support rules that do so, but clarity on what constitutes targeting is needed.”

The no-call added tension to a game already filled with drama. Texas had squandered a 16-point lead in regulation before rallying in double overtime for the win. The victory propels the Longhorns to the College Football Playoff semifinals.

For Arizona State, the loss leaves lingering questions about officiating and the implementation of targeting rules, which continue to spark debate across college football.